kantopia

FE Heroes “Choose Your Legends” Poll Results Analysis

xkan
Advertisements

Nintendo conducted a poll for Fire Emblem Heroes urging fans to pick a favorite character of theirs that they would love to see featured. Each fan could vote once a day for 13 days for almost any character from any of the Fire Emblem series of games.

The competition had since ended, and results posted. Nintendo reported an overall outcome of 1.2 million votes. As you can imagine the selection was quite vast!

I thought it may be fun to take a look at the results and analyze/comment on them!

Some things to keep in mind before we get started:

Results: Male characters

Rank Name Game Votes
1 Ike FE9 33,871
2 Roy FE6 28,982
3 Hector FE7 26,557
4 Chrom FE13 23,803
5 Ike FE10 17,684
6 Marth FE1/11 15,877
7 Ephraim FE8 14,908
8 Robin (M) FE13 14,149
9 Takumi FE14 12,662
10 Leo FE14 12,175
11 Henry FE13 12,131
12 Dorcas FE7 12,083
13 Donnel FE13 10,479
14 Lon’qu FE13 10,002
15 Gaius FE13 9,465
16 Niles FE14 8,703
17 Marth FE3/12 8,670
18 Joshua FE8 8,623
19 Eliwood FE7 8,393
20 Owain FE13 8,383

Notes to ponder on the above:

There’s a lot of fun data in here. Ike won by quite a margin, a full 5000+ vote lead on Roy. This was only accounting for the (slimmer) Path of Radiance Ike as well. The combined numbers presented above give an idea of how the character alone would fare. I suppose on could argue that it was voting for which depiction of Ike fans preferred, both in character and physique.

However, for Marth who had not changed much between the games, the split vote hurt him much more. He ended up in 6th place, whereas with combined votes he would’ve ended up above Chrom in 4th place. That’s a pretty big jump! A reason for this was perhaps the fact FE12 (a remake of 3) had not come out in the west, where as FE11 (a remake of FE1) had come as Shadow Dragon. Of course it may have been to keep things simple too.

You can see in terms of most characters, including non-leads, Awakening won this category by far. It makes sense as the game that “saved the series” and brought an influx of new fans (and won many old ones) with its varied cast of characters that stuck out. Fates follows and ties with Blazing Blade in terms of the runner up of characters, with three each. It seemed in that sense, Awakening had set a better standard when it came to characters presented!

The biggest surprises for me, personally, are Hector in third place and Ephraim in seventh. Hector is one of the three main lords from Blazing Blade, and has had no significant Smash Bros representation. Ephraim is similar appearing in Sacred Stones as one of the two main characters. It is surprising they managed to beat out fan favorites from Fates (Takumi and Leo) despite being in games that came out much longer ago.

Perhaps there was an old sense of love for them, considering Hector is often cited as favorite FE rep for Smash Bros due to wielding an axe rather than a sword –Ephraim for the same reason as he wields a lance. Both the above games are available on the Virtual Console as well, getting around the issue many who want to play Ike’s games (the Tellius games) have with high priced GC/Wii prices on the secondhand market.

Ike had won a popularity contest in Famitsu as well, with his Smash Bros. representation likely carrying him this far. Indeed, he has appeared in Fates as an amiibo bonus as well. Love for him has continued to be strong despite the lower sales on the two console games!

Corrin (male) did not make this list despite appearing in the latest Smash Bros. game. There can be several reasons. For one, being a DLC character that one must pay for may have already turned off those who were unfamiliar with him and held little interest. Essentially, it would be Fire Emblem fans or people who were willing to pay for more characters in Smash Bros. that would be willing to pay for him, rather than a general player. Roy is DLC in the latest game too, but appeared included in the beloved second game of the series ( Melee ) so was likely not effected as much.

The other possibility is his unpopularity among Fire Emblem fans in general who experienced Fates and were less than pleased with his character. That is not to say he does not have fans, though. If you see the midterm results (farther down the page), you will see he originally had made it to the top 20 before being replaced.

However, a potential counter-argument is that perhaps more simply voted for his female counterpart (which is true, see more in the next section).

Consider Robin, who has a female counterpart. He made it to this list and was a non-DLC newcomer to Smash Bros for 3DS and Wii U. He has been around in Fire Emblem slightly longer (Awakening), and was slightly less controversial as a character.

Dorcas placing this high I assume was due to memeification after the midterm results (and perhaps even from before) and definitely sticks out as the oddball of this entire list, considering he is the second favorite non-main male it seems!

Results: Female characters

Rank Name Game Votes
1 Lyn FE7 49,917
2 Lucina FE13 42,875
3 Tharja FE13 29,540
4 Camilla FE14 25,766
5 Corrin (F) FE14 19,599
6 Eirika FE8 16,423
7 Cordelia FE13 14,362
8 Azura FE14 14,198
9 Micaiah FE10 13,491
10 Nowi FE13 10,571
11 Robin (F) FE13 10,387
12 Tiki FE13 9,794
13 Lute FE8 9,176
14 Felicia FE14 9,121
15 Elise FE14 8,962
16 Mia FE10 8,946
17 Anna FE13 8,431
18 Nephenee FE9 7,916
19 Nino FE7 7,825
20 Sakura FE14 7,782

Notes to ponder on the above:

The female character chart reveals something very different. Lyn won with a 7000 vote lead, likely thanks to her already standing popularity as seen in the Famitsu poll, status as first (widely) known female lord, and status in Smash Bros. as an assist trophy that may have raised interest.

Right after is fan favorites Lucina, Tharja, and Camilla, who were pretty much expected to place near the top (especially with Japanese fans considered). Nowi made it pretty high, likely thanks to her support on the Japanese side of things, as her western popularity is often controversial.

Two big things: There are more Kozaki-era characters (FE13/14) on here (13) than on the other chart. With that, the winning members here had scores much higher individually than their male counterparts. This goes back to what I said before about only being able to cast one vote toward one gender character or the other, which means many more may have cast a vote for a female character than not.

A possible reason for this may be the marriage system that exists in both Awakening and Fates that would have allowed player attachments to these characters to form, and thus be more memorable when it came to voting. Lyn and Lucina’s roles (and Lucina’s as both role and potential daughter or wife depending on decision) may have contributed to their top scores above the rest.

That leaves Eirika as an interesting pick for 6th place, as her game is often overshadowed by the ones that surround it.

Corrin (Female) appears in the top 5 here, a huge contrast to her male counterpart! It can be a case of most preferring the female Corrin based on appearance or more fitting to the “role” of the Princess caught in between two families.  It shows that perhaps it is not the “character” at fault, and merely that people preferred to vote for the female incarnation. Remember they could only vote one way. More on this in the next section.

You can see female Robin appears here too, losing to the female Corrin. That is a note to consider for the next section.

Comparing both genders

Rank Name Game Votes
1 Lyn FE7 49,917
2 Lucina FE13 42,875
3 Ike FE9 33,871
4 Tharja FE13 29,540
5 Roy FE6 28,982
6 Hector FE7 26,557
7 Camilla FE14 25,766
8 Chrom FE13 23,803
9 Corrin (F) FE14 19,599
10 Ike FE10 17,684
11 Eirika FE8 16,423
12 Marth FE1/11 15,877
13 Ephraim FE8 14,908
14 Cordelia FE13 14,362
15 Azura FE14 14,198
16 Robin (M) FE13 14,149
17 Micaiah FE10 13,491
18 Takumi FE14 12,662
19 Leo FE14 12,175
20 Henry FE13 12,131

Notes to ponder on the above:

When we look at them combined, we see some common trends on both lists. For one, Lyn had the most individual uncombined votes, beating the male counterpart (Ike) by far. Placing top may be due to her continued presence in Smash Bros. as an assist trophy, as well as the fact she was one of the earlier DLC characters for Awakening as well. This would aid new fans in recognizing her, as well as fans of Smash Bros. but not particularly Fire Emblem who would have taken interest in her.

Awakening has the most characters on this list, followed by Fates. It makes sense for the two recent installments that were also among the most popular games that brought in new fans to have many of the voted favorites. Awakening placed top for “favorite game” on the Famitsu poll as well.

The beloved Jugdral games (FE4 and 5) did not appear on any of the polls (and many of their characters actually placed in last). This may be due to the lack of official worldwide representation for them, as well as lack of Smash Bros. representation as well. The games are old enough that many Japanese fans who had played them may no longer be interested in the series, or actively participating in it. There are many reasons why the game likely did not place at all.

Roy of Binding Blade came in an impressive top spot, likely owing it to his Smash Bros. Melee debut that helped bring the games to the west in the first place. The rest of the Binding Blade cast were lower than the games that were released westward.

In addition to Roy, the other characters seen in the Smash Bros. games all appeared, likely again due to already being familiar to many who would have voted.

Ike wins out if his votes are combined, however, soaring above Lyn’s count. But it can be argued that Ike’s character (in both appearance and personality) is different enough between the two versions (FE9 and 10) to keep them separate. This is quite interesting considering the Tellius games are notably harder to find and did not sell too much compared to the other Fire Emblem games.

Marth however is more of the same, but is still split between two here –and even when combined only increases his standing enough to beat only Chrom.

Hector earns a special place at 6th, impressive because he lacks any notable Smash Bros. representation or any real representation outside of Blazing Blade. He’s also my site mascot’s father, so this is nice to see on a personal level, too!

Micaiah (placed 17th) is also a pleasant surprise, as Radiant Dawn had sold relatively little compared to the other games as mentioned with Ike, and she is quite a controversial character even among the fanbase.

Robin (Male) beat Robin (Female). Perhaps what I said on Corrin (Female) being the preferred applied in reverse to Robin’s situation. (Perhaps more perceive Robin as Lucina’s husband-to-be rather than mother? Or perhaps preferred him paired with another female character entirely?) There can be many reasons, but vote-wise the male one certainly won out. It may be worth noting his default amiibo is male too!

Regarding female Corrin, If these people voted for male Corrin instead, the character would have ended up right below Chrom. If combined with the female Corrin’s votes, he would have been even higher, above Hector. Their vote differential was the largest between counterparts on the top spaces, with female scoring 19,599 and male only 7,691 (11,908). It is a much bigger difference than male and female Robin, who had 14,149 and 10,387 votes respectively (making a difference of 3762 votes).

I was more reluctant to combine the different genders as their appearances of course would be notably different. The appearance (and arguably gender) goes a long way on these votes as the data show. However, their characters are more or less the same (with minor changes to apply to genders when it comes to marriage).

Ike on the other hand between FE9/10 is a similar character, but also looks significantly different between titles. This once again comes back to Marth who is the only one who would not have changed significantly between his games. Perhaps it was to avoid all these exceptions that they decided to split the votes among different incarnations of the same character. Considering the top places would get special appearances, their looks were indeed more important than simply popularity as a character, and rather as a character as they appear in a certain game/form.

Characters hurt most by a split vote were those featured in multiple games not set too far apart from each other. (The Tellius games, for example, as a vast majority of the characters are the same, considering the game was not too long after). Nephenee, for instance, may have placed higher if her votes were combined despite her character and appearance being nearly identical.

The overall vote differences I mentioned in the notes (226,171 female character votes versus 212,799 male character ones) also make for an interesting question. If you combine the above two, that makes 438,970 votes. Now if voters were not limited to one character overall, and instead one character per gender, how would the results have changed, if at all? That is a significantly larger amount, and it would have been interesting to see how those who voted for a female character would have voted for a male character (and vice versa).

For instance, I myself did not vote any male characters, even though there were plenty I wanted to see and would’ve voted for had I not been limited to one per either gender character per day!

Lastly, there is one key point I wanted to look at, in addition to the point I mentioned above:

Differences from the mid-term ranking:


 So the midterm standing list (seen above) looks more or less like the final list.

Some changes:

Male:

Female:

Overall, you can see that the order largely remained the same. The only one who lost their overall footing was Corrin (Male), with Eliwood appearing.

The match was closer with the 11-20 female characters who shifted around in place slightly, but there was no upset to the top picks, who seem to have already solidified their position by midterm.

The potential issue with revealing midterm results may have contributed, however. People who voted their favorites from more niche titles may have abandoned them for the next several days to vote for their favorites on this list. That would mean the competition becomes fierce among the contenders who already made it this far, skewing the overall popularity in favor for those who were overall by midterm.

This is not completely true nor able to be discerned with full certainty from this list alone, however. Eliwood, for instance, took Corrin (Male) off his place and came up despite not appearing here at all, meaning he may have had some faithful still voting for him regardless of his lack of appearance on this chart. It can also be a case of these characters being so far ahead in midterm already that it would not matter as the rest of the votes were scattered among so many characters.

Still, it is important to note how some may abandon voting on who they want versus who they want from this chart. For that reason I still bring it up as a potential game changer.

Many have commented and agreed they changed their votes to any they saw on this list, abandoning who they originally intended to vote for (of course, there are those who stuck with it, too!)

Conclusion

Ike and Lyn’s popularity remains high, as do the other characters that are featured in the Smash Bros. series. Outside of that, Awakening and Fates’ characters flex their popularity by appearing in the largest numbers on these lists. With high sales, recent relevance, and plenty of fans (both old and new) behind them, the lists become more or less what people would expect from an overall popularity poll.

Overall, it seems the most important factor was exposure, as evident by the amount of main characters that appear, notably the Smash Bros characters. Many of the non-Smash Bros characters were from the more recent games as well as those that faced worldwide release. Which makes sense for what essentially becomes a popularity contest, right?

There were some limitations to the polling (as noted throughout the article when relevant), but should give a good idea at where characters stand overall with these in mind.

So who did you vote for? Did they make it to the list? What place did they come in? Only one of mine (Mia) placed on the female list at 17! My favorite character and site mascot (Lilina) was nowhere to be seen (she was farther down at 49, top 50, at least! Yay!)

But hey, her father made it! I am quite content.

Please share any thoughts you may have too below, or anything else you may deem worthy of analysis!

Advertisements

Advertisements