kantopia

FE9 and FE10 (Tellius Games) “Choose Your Legends” Poll Results Analysis

Advertisements

Nintendo conducted a poll for Fire Emblem Heroes urging fans to pick a favorite character of theirs that they would love to see featured. Each fan could vote once a day for 13 days for almost any character from any of the main Fire Emblem series of games.

This is part of a miniseries I am doing on analyzing the vast amount of poll data available to us and what it means for the fandom and their favorites regarding characters.

Thanks to the tireless work of Elieson over on serenesforest.net, we can take a look at the break downs by game!

Today we will focus on FE9 (Path of Radiance) and FE10 (Radiant Dawn) which together form the Tellius saga/games.

There are some general things to keep in mind before we get started, however.

Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance (FE9)

In-Game Placing Overall Place Character Total Votes
1 3 Ike 33871
2 38 Nephenee 7916
3 45 Soren 6248
4 54 Black Knight 5317
5 67 Mia 4408
6 107 Titania 2588
7 150 Ilyana 1858
8 154 Lethe 1780
9 167 Mist 1581
10 171 Ranulf 1550
11 175 Jill 1538
12 207 Shinon 1200
13 258 Haar 880
14 262 Elincia 858
15 264 Tibarn 838
16 268 Marcia 835
17 281 Greil 762
18 292 Astrid 697
19 308 Oscar 652
20 309 Leanne 649
21 313 Mordecai 635
22 321 Boyd 614
23 330 Zihark 577
24 336 Stefan 550
25 342 Naesala 528
26 346 Sanaki 520
27 347 Reyson 520
28 354 Volke 501
29 356 Lucia 491
30 359 Rolf 482
31 360 Rhys 476
32 364 Sothe 469
33 366 Ashnard 465
34 379 Kieran 431
35 412 Tormod 347
36 414 Caineghis 345
37 421 Petrine 325
38 438 Janaff 299
39 440 Muarim 295
40 446 Zelgius 286
41 451 Gatrie 280
42 455 Sigrun 276
43 479 Elena 250
44 483 Brom 245
45 498 Tanith 230
46 507 Devdan 223
47 552 Geoffrey 161
48 564 Largo 150
49 587 Ena 135
50 591 Calill 132
51 593 Makalov 131
52 604 Nasir 124
53 621 Ulki 108
54 638 Kurthnaga 99
55 644 Bertram 97
56 656 Giffca 89
57 667 Tauroneo 82
58 670 Bastian 80
59 671 Sephiran 80
60 673 Gareth 76
61 688 Renning 68
62 719 Dheginsea 57
63 744 Nealuchi 45

Notes:

One can clearly see how Ike carried this game, making up a whopping 38% of the game’s votes alone. The vote gap between Ike and the next in place, Nephenee, is the most significant across the charts, showing that Ike alone has more representation than other characters in this game –likely due to Smash Bros fame much like Roy.

Path of Radiance was a Gamecube (and hence console) Fire Emblem game that did not really sell too much (relative to other games in the series) which may factor into relatively little amount of people playing the game (indeed, as it had the least sales out of Fire Emblem games that came west). It is also notoriously hard to find, and quite expensive on second hand sites. There are no virtual console options unlike FE7 and FE8 that have seen GBA VC releases. As such, this game and its sequel are still rather illusive, and the numbers for Ike versus the rest of the cast certainly shows!

Not counting Shadow Dragon, FE9 was also the least voted for western-released Fire Emblem game, which may reflect those low sales numbers.

Looking at second place, Nephenee is often cited as a favorite in design and character by fans, but it was surprising she beat Soren. Soren is a main character (and tactician of the game, meaning one could argue he is technically a extension of the player), and was often the assumed second place contender for the game. This loss can possibly attribute to, again, how despite a split gender votes, only one vote could be cast either way (see general notes at the top for issues in this way of polling). It is interesting she placed higher than Elincia, the female protagonist with a greater role in the story, though in this case it may have to do purely with design.

When it comes to just male characters, he indeed placed second on the in-game chart, which would line up with initial assumptions.

The Black Knight places very high for a central antagonist of the game, beating out the rest of them (if you account for exceptions in Fates of course, see notes above). It may have to do with his constant presence and clashes with Ike. Considering his memorable theme song made it into Smash Bros. as well may be a contributing factor. Consider the other main antagonist, Ashnard, placed somewhere in the middle at 33.

Mia, a female Myrmidon, continues the trend of the high ranking characters of her class. However, unlike Joshua and Marisa in FE8 or Rutger and Fir in FE6, her male counterpart Zihark placed much farther down in 23rd place, right next to the other Swordmaster of the game, Stefan. It seems perhaps the male Myrmidon/Swordmasters didn’t place that well (compared to the female) this time around, breaking another trend.

Titania, like Seth, is a pre-promoted paladin from the start of the game who continues to have a presence in the story. For this reason she likely placed higher than most pre-promotes (or Jagen characters) do.

Lethe placed highest laguz this time, with Ranulf following up slightly farther down the list, though Tibarn is close behind. Tibarn is interesting because he is only playable in the very late game, but his ongoing story presence likely made him memorable to players.

Greil placed on the top 20, rare for someone who is more of an early game presence and an otherwise non-playable character for the main story.

When we look toward the bottom of the list, we see the last five places are NPCs who only really exist in the story; some that are mention a few times offhand (like Renning in 61st). As such, Bastian is the lowest placing playable character, which may be attributed to him being pre-promoted and a late game entry.

Makalov, notable for not being the most favorite of many fans, placed rather low as expected –though still beat out Nasir and Ulki. Ena and Calill, the least voted female characters, still won out above him, but all lost to Devdan, who is a bit of a running joke among staff as well.

To fully understand the Tellius results though, we have to take a look at Radiant Dawn to see where some of these votes may have went (or, in Ike’s case, were taken from).

Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn (FE10)

In-Game Placing Overall Place Character Total Votes
1 10 Ike 17684
2 17 Micaiah 13491
3 31 Mia 8946
4 50 Nephenee 5557
5 58 Black Knight 4878
6 82 Soren 3470
7 97 Sothe 2863
8 104 Haar 2678
9 112 Elincia 2502
10 148 Tibarn 1872
11 160 Ilyana 1696
12 168 Ranulf 1578
13 170 Shinon 1553
14 182 Edward 1446
15 183 Jill 1437
16 189 Mist 1391
17 198 Sanaki 1308
18 205 Nailah 1206
19 206 Zelgius 1202
20 211 Titania 1169
21 217 Volke 1131
22 218 Naesala 1128
23 244 Zihark 975
24 255 Oliver 902
25 261 Lucia 861
26 265 Volug 838
27 266 Lethe 836
28 277 Leanne 788
29 300 Vika 681
30 302 Stefan 675
31 303 Tormod 668
32 311 Aran 648
33 319 Caineghis 616
34 322 Pelleas 608
35 323 Heather 599
36 328 Boyd 587
37 345 Anna 523
38 351 Marcia 517
39 352 Meg 516
40 367 Reyson 462
41 368 Lyre 460
42 377 Rolf 434
43 381 Yune 428
44 386 Geoffrey 422
45 393 Leonardo 398
46 404 Sephiran 367
47 406 Amy 364
48 422 Sigrun 323
49 424 Astrid 321
50 426 Ashera 316
51 428 Oscar 315
52 430 Laura 312
53 439 Nolan 297
54 448 Gatrie 282
55 453 Muarim 279
56 471 Rhys 258
57 478 Mordecai 250
58 480 Kurthnaga 247
59 482 Kieran 246
60 486 Skrimir 244
61 508 Brom 221
62 509 Ashunera 221
63 517 Fiona 212
64 531 Janaff 187
65 538 Dheginsea 174
66 565 Rafiel 149
67 568 Jarod 146
68 573 Kyza 142
69 579 Danved 140
70 583 Tauroneo 137
71 597 Tanith 129
72 598 Calill 129
73 605 Gareth 122
74 607 Aimee 120
75 610 Ulki 118
76 618 Bastian 110
77 649 Ena 96
78 653 Almedha 93
79 654 Nasir 93
80 658 Giffca 88
81 662 Makalov 85
82 663 Renning 85
83 724 Valtome 55
84 739 Nealuchi 47
85 740 Largo 46
86 757 Muston 39
87 758 Jorge 39
88 770 Izuka 33
89 772 Hetzel 33
90 777 Daniel 29

Notes:

We see a different story here compared to Path of Radiance. For one, Ike did place first but by a much slimmer margin. Though his Smash Bros. fame is one potential reason for him still placing highest, it may be due to fan preference (taking Japan into account) for the slimmer FE9 appearance. He has gotten notably bigger in FE10, and while welcomed by some fans, others preferred his appearance (and characterization) in FE9. It is likely his split vote is why he has fewer numbers here than there.

Micaiah, the female protagonist and cover girl of this game, placed highest for female character. Though her character and actions in the story is divisive, her importance to the story is undeniable (to the extent it bothers fans), as well as pure exposure. Many who have not played the game are fond of her design, and she had appeared in Awakening as a DLC character (albeit with a significantly different design). She had no split vote affecting her, and so she placed rather high up.

Mia once again placed high, beating Nephenee for next highest female character. Mia’s design in FE10 looks much more different than her FE9 appearance compared to Nephenee between the games, which may be a factor. Mia was also featured in a CGI scene in the game (with a voice, too), that Nephenee did not, perhaps boosting her presence. Nephenee probably has more exposure story-wise, however, whereas Mia has just one base conversation. This means that ether her votes came from fans of her design, or perhaps from the FE9 fans who got to see more of her character in support conversations and then voted for her FE10 incarnation.

Note that Mia’s FE10 form appeared on the midterm results in 17th place for female characters, which may be another reason that those who may have voted for her FE9 appearance swung for the FE10 one instead.

The male myrmidon of the game, Edward, placed lower down the list and off from Mia by quite a margin (~7000 votes), once again breaking trends set by Rutger/Fir and Joshua/Marisa.

The Black Knight appears here in fifth place, continuing his trend as a popular antagonist, due to similar reasons as FE9. He even beat Soren, however, which is interesting. Soren’s FE10 appearance scored generally lower than his FE9 one, much like Ike’s case. His role in the story was still there as well as other revelations with his character, so it may purely be by design/personal preference.

Sothe, a main character of this game who was just another unit of the previous game, managed to place after Soren.

Tibarn comes in as highest ranked laguz of the game, whereas Lethe fell down to 27th place. Nailah beat Lethe for title of highest ranking female laguz –likely due to her sheer power, unique type, and ongoing story presence. Tibarn managed to outdo Ranulf, who has quite the story presence and character among fans too.

Shinon managed to keep around the same rank in both games, his sharp-tongue quite memorable for fans –but his status as a better unit in this game probably a contributing factor too.

Titania placed much lower on the scale compared to FE9. It may be due to only joining in part 3 of the game with a diminished role. With so many other characters to choose from and less speaking role, it may have contributed to this.

Sanaki on the other hand placed much higher relative to position in FE9, now entering the top 20. This is likely due to increased story role as well as being a playable character.

Zelgius placed higher here too, again likely due to increased story role, though he remains an NPC.

Oliver placed notably high at 24 for what is essentially a joke character (among the devs and the fans). One thing to note is that he did not have a split vote, as he had no option to vote for in FE9. It may mean his votes were all concentrated to one place which is what let him place so high.

As we look toward the bottom of the list, we see many of the Dawn Brigade members placing generally lower. They do have their fans, but perhaps they fell for being out-shined by other characters in the game –as like with Micaiah, their placement and role in the game can be controversial.

At the very bottom of the list is Daniel, in charge of one of the shops. Nealuchi, who placed lowest in FE9, is still here though, despite being playable. I suppose his design and character just did not appeal to many.

The infamous Makalov remains near the bottom too, though Calill placed relatively higher, bumping Ena down (where as their roles were reversed last time). Almedha still placed lower than Ena for lowest ranked overall female character however.

Bastian, the lowest ranked playable character of the last game, still placed low with Ulki (another who was near the bottom last time). A lot of these characters are late-game pre-promotes (Renning, Bastian, etc), but those like Ulki and Nealuchi may just be due to their unconventional designs that many fans may not be used to these days (or even in those days).

Kyza is notable for being forgettable (ironically), and his poll results reflect this.

Even with a strange change of name, Danved still placed low like Devdan did.

It is interesting that Valtome and Hetzel are included, but Lekain (who was a more significant antagonist) is missing.

All in all, it seems the games suffer the most from a split vote, much like the Archanea games did. As such, I decided to combine the votes to take a look at for informational purposes. See below!

Combined votes (Tellius saga):

 

Rank Character Votes
1 Ike 51555
2 Micaiah 13491
3 Nephenee 13473
4 Mia 13354
5 Black Knight 10195
6 Soren 9718
7 Titania 3757
8 Haar 3558
9 Ilyana 3554
10 Elincia 3360
11 Sothe 3332
12 Ranulf 3128
13 Jill 2975
14 Mist 2972
15 Shinon 2753
16 Tibarn 2710
17 Lethe 2616
18 Sanaki 1828
19 Naesala 1656
20 Volke 1632
21 Zihark 1552
22 Zelgius 1488
23 Edward 1446
24 Leanne 1437
25 Marcia 1352
26 Lucia 1352
27 Stefan 1225
28 Nailah 1206
29 Boyd 1201
30 Astrid 1018
31 Tormod 1015
32 Reyson 982
33 Oscar 967
34 Caineghis 961
35 Rolf 916
36 Oliver 902
37 Mordecai 885
38 Volug 838
39 Greil 762
40 Rhys 734
41 Vika 681
42 Kieran 677
43 Aran 648
44 Pelleas 608
45 Sigrun 599
46 Heather 599
47 Geoffrey 583
48 Muarim 574
49 Gatrie 562
50 Anna 523
51 Meg 516
52 Janaff 486
53 Brom 466
54 Ashnard 465
55 Lyre 460
56 Sephiran 447
57 Yune 428
58 Leonardo 398
59 Amy 364
60 Devdan 363
61 Tanith 359
62 Kurthnaga 346
63 Petrine 325
64 Ashera 316
65 Laura 312
66 Nolan 297
67 Calill 261
68 Elena 250
69 Skrimir 244
70 Ena 231
71 Dheginsea 231
72 Ulki 226
73 Ashunera 221
74 Tauroneo 219
75 Nasir 217
76 Makalov 216
77 Fiona 212
78 Gareth 198
79 Largo 196
80 Bastian 190
81 Giffca 177
82 Renning 153
83 Rafiel 149
84 Jarod 146
85 Kyza 142
86 Aimee 120
87 Bertram 97
88 Almedha 93
89 Nealuchi 92
90 Valtome 55
91 Muston 39
92 Jorge 39
93 Izuka 33
94 Hetzel 33
95 Daniel 29

 

Notes:

Wow, what a difference the combined scores make. One important thing to get out of the way first is acknowledging why the games had a split vote. Some characters don’t change much between games, such as Nephenee. Someone like Ike, however, was quite different in his appearance as well as somewhat in his character. Appearance is the more notable one here, though, as the original goal of this poll was to gauge which characters fans would want to see in a new outfit, and hence, appearance. It would make a difference to vote for the slimmer FE9 Ike to the buff FE10 one.

So if they were to keep Ike split but Nephenee combined, there would likely be issues with who is an exception and who isn’t. As such, for simplicity, votes were split simply by game. While it is a questionable polling method that harmed some characters (as you can see on the poll), it is understandable why it was done this way.

Getting to the numbers though, if they had been combined, Ike would be top contender across the board. His Smash Bros fame must be the largest contribution considering the Tellis games sold least in the series (since it came west). Micaiah’s numbers are telling, the huge gap between Ike and Micaiah reflecting the stark difference of Smash Bros. representation versus not (such as, again, Roy and Lilina in FE6).

However, that is not to underestimate Micaiah’s popularity, considering she still beat a combined Nephenee and Mia (though, by not that much). Consider Micaiah’s role in the story versus these other two, and you will see those slim votes are really telling. Nephenee and Mia combined would have topped Nowi on the overall female poll for 10th and 11th places respectively.

Likewise, the Black Knight would remain highest scoring antagonist (with the usual exceptions) and place below Donnel and above Lon’qu for highest scoring males.

Soren, even when combined, still falls below the 10,000 mark. He would place higher on the male chart above Gaius in 15th, but not by much.

After Soren, there is a big drop off again, falling from 9000 to 3000 in a single placement. It starts to peter off from there.

At the bottom of the combined list we have NPCs, antagonists, pre-promotes, etc. The lowest scoring playable character is hence Kyza, in 85th place! He is the lowest ranking laguz too. He just doesn’t get a break.

It’s a little sad that Hetzel scored lower than Valtome… I suppose indecision was deemed a worse trait than being a despicable senator!

Conclusion:

When it comes to the numbers, Smash Bros. makes a huge difference in votes. Ike’s presence in the Smash Bros. series since Brawl makes him recognizable to audiences beyond the Fire Emblem fanbase. The evidence lies in the fact that the Tellius games’ had lower sales than others that came west, yet Ike scored higher than many in those other games (beating Hector in FE7, Ephraim in FE8, Chrom in FE13, etc). Even when uncombined, his FE9 incarnation placed number one, and his FE10 self also placed on the top 20. It is quite telling.

Micaiah tells the story of Tellius games without much Smash Bros. representation, much farther down than Ike (though still out doing others in her game quite well). Even after combined results, she places highest for female character.

The Black Knight placed extremely high for a primary antagonist, though as I stated before, it depends on your definition of “antagonist” (considering the Fates siblings could be too depending on the path).

The ones who suffered the most from the split vote are hence those like Nephenee and Mia. They would have placed much higher overall had their votes not been split, especially Nephenee who’s changes are negligible between the games. Of course, keep in mind what I wrote in the notes regarding why votes were split, due to the exceptions probably only leading to complications.

The bottom of the lists usually are late game pre-promotes, NPCs, antagonists –or Makalov and Kyza, characters that were already unpopular within the fanbase.

The overall votes for Path of Radiance and Radiant Dawn were split among many, many characters (especially in the latter game), making what seems like impressive numbers at first dwindle down when looked at as purely votes per character. The lack of VC options for these games makes them hardly accessible to those aiming to play them –another reason that Ike was the one who shot far above the other characters of this game.


That wraps up the Tellius saga! Tomorrow we journey to the “new” era of Fire Emblem games, looking at Awakening and what a difference the influx of fans made to the series and the poll as a whole.

As usual, feel free to leave any comments you may have or observations of your own below!

Advertisements

Advertisements