A fellow translator and FE fan over on Twitter was curious as to a certain post’s legitimacy, that is, a claim that before Fire Emblem x Shin Megami Tensei, there were plans for it to be Fire Emblem x Pokemon.
After some searching for the Nintendo Dream issue it had apparently come from (Dec. 21 2015 issue), a twitter follower came forward saying they had it, and provided me the scans. So, let’s please give a HUGE thank you to @nohrianpeach for not only providing the scan for that particular page, but for all the FE pages from this issue.
It turned out this particular segment is actually in the companion booklet that came with the magazine, rather than the magazine itself.
And so, here is the snippet translated. It turns out it is true, too! (I provide the transcript in Japanese below too, but the shot itself won’t be posted here. It is available by request however). It is only mentioned in passing in the first paragraph.
Please tell us what led up to the planning of Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE.
Yamagami (Nintendo Producer): 5 years ago, Ms. Andou proposed a plan [for a crossover], saying “You know, I think FE and Pokemon‘s rules are pretty compatible!” Though I agreed with her, by chance the Pokemon group had already proposed what eventually became Pokemon Conquest at the same time [so we were unable to follow through].
Andou (Nintendo Director): Yes, which I was in charge of too.
Yamagami (Nintendo Producer): As the plan was a secret, she was put in charge of that first. (Laughs). And then, it took her less than a week to say, “Here’s the next plan.” The new plan was a collaboration with Atlus. At that time, new games like Xenoblade and Pandora’s Tower were coming out, and, because I myself was quite interested in Atlus’s games, I figured “This could work!” At first, we made informal plans within our own small group, but…
Takata (Atlus Producer): At that time, the organization itself was undergoing changes. and it was almost impossible to deal with Atlus as a second party, and so we almost decided to give up on it. After roughtly 2 years, we heard from Hiraoka (board member at Atlus), “Let’s try to collaborate and level up by making an RPG together.” After that, we attempted to contact Nintendo repeatedly, asking “Do you want to bring that RPG to life [with us]?”
Yamagami (Nintendo Producer): We replied immediately with, “Let’s do it!” We then quickly began to draft plans for the game, still only having a rough idea of what it would be. And so, we released an image that showed, “Shin Megami Tensei Meets Fire Emblem” to the public.
And that’s that! There’s more to the interview regarding the development of TMS#FE that I may get to later, but right at the start they mention the potential Pokemon collaboration that didn’t come to be due to Pokemon Conquest.
Imagine how FE x Pokemon would’ve been? Though, Pokemon Conquest itself was quite a fun game! So I don’t entirely mind having gotten that at the expense of the other game, personally.
Once again, thanks to @shadwofchaos725 for bringing it to my attention, and @nohrianpeach for the scans!
Original transcript:
ć¼ć幻影ē°čé²ļ¼ļ¼¦ļ¼„ćć®ä¼ē»ćē«ć”ććć£ććć£ćććęćć¦ćć ććć
å±±äøćļ¼å¹“ć¾ććå®č¤ćććļ¼¦ļ¼„ļ¼½ć®ć«ć¼ć«ćØććć±ć¢ć³ćć®ēøę§ćÆéåøøć«ćććØęććć§ććć©ććØä¼ē»ćęę”ćć¦ććććØććć£ććć§ćććåććććØęć£ććć§ććććć¾ćć¾åćæć¤ćć³ć°ć§ćć±ć¢ć³ććććććć±ć¢ć³ļ¼ćććć¬ć®éęćļ¼ļ¼ćęę”ććć¾ćć¦ć
å®č¤ććÆćććććÆē§ćę å½ćć¾ććć
å±±äøćä¼ē»ćč¢«ć£ćć®ć§ćć¾ććÆćć”ććę å½ćć¦ćććØļ¼ē¬ļ¼ćććććććå®č¤ćäøé±éćććŖććć”ć«ćꬔć®ä¼ē»ć§ććć£ć¦ćę°ććŖä¼ē»ćęć£ć¦ę„ććć§ćććććć¢ćć©ć¹ćććØć®ć³ć©ćä¼ē»ć§ćććå½ęćć¼ććć¬ć¤ćććØćććć³ćć©ć®å”ććØćć£ćę°ćććæć¤ćć«ć«ęę¦ćć¦ćć¾ććććåčŖčŗ«ćć¢ćć©ć¹ććć®ä½åć«čå³ććć£ćć®ć§ćććććććØęć£ććć§ććć§ćć¾ććÆå ć ć«ćęę”ćććć§ććć©ć»ć»ć»ć
é«ē°ćåęćć©ć¤ć³ē·Øęć®čŖæę“ćć¤ććŖćć£ćć®ćØćć¢ćć©ć¹ć§ć»ć«ć³ććć¼ćć¤ćØćć¦åćēµćć ććØćć»ć¼ē”ćć£ćć®ć§ćäøę¦ćÆä¼ē¤¾ćØćć¦č¦éććØććå¤ęć§ććććć®ććØćļ¼å¹“ććććć¦ććć¦ćć®å¹³å²”ćććāę“ćŖćć¬ćć«ć¢ććć®åć«ć»ć«ć³ććØćć¦ć®ļ¼²ļ¼°ļ¼§éēŗć«ćęę¦ćć¦ćæććāćØććå¤ęćććććć®č©±ēćć¦ćć¾ćļ¼ććØå¼ē¤¾ććę¹ćć¦ä»»å¤©å ććć«ćé£ēµ”ćć¾ććć
å±±äøććēćć¦ć¾ćļ¼ćć£ć¦ćććć«ļ¼Æļ¼«ććć¦äøęć«ä¼ē»ćē«ć¦ć¾ćć¦ćć¾ć čćē¶ę ć ć£ććć§ććć©ćēć»å„³ē„č»¢ēļ¼ļ¼„ļ¼„ļ¼“ļ¼³ćć”ć¤ć¢ć¼ćØć ćć¬ć ćć£ć¦ē»åć ććå ¬éćć¾ććć
Pingback: Fire Emblem's Totally Normal and Sane Crossovers | IGN Video
Pingback: Three Years of Kantopia & the End of the Daily Blog | kantopia
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover - Game News & Information | Info4Games
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover | The Blog Box
Pingback: Ī¤Īæ Ī¹ĻĻĪæĻĪ¹ĪŗĻ ĻĪæĻ crossover - ĻĻĪæĻĪ¬ĻĪæĻĪ± ĻĪæĻ Tokyo Mirage Sessions - Nintendo Next
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE pudo haber sido un juego entre Fire Emblem y PokƩmon | Atomix
Pingback: Un crossover entre PokƩmon et Fire Emblem a ƩtƩ envisagƩ
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover | GamesNews Pro - News, PC Games, Video Games, Previews
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover | GamesPlus - News, PC Games, Video Games, Previews
Pingback: We Almost Got a Fire Emblem & Pokemon Crossover Instead of Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover | Art of War Gaming
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover - newtech 21
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover | News Post Pro
Pingback: Un Juego de Fire Emblem x PokĆ©mon habĆa sido considerado por Nintendo. – NINtheorist
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokĆ©mon Crossover – TechBabbler
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover - Arcade Bulletin
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokĆ©mon Crossover – Game News
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover - Writing Service Pro
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokĆ©mon Crossover – GEEKDOMO
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover | MnS Web Reviews
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokƩmon Crossover | Nancy's GM Reviews
Pingback: The Digital Download » Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokĆ©mon Crossover
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokĆ©mon Crossover – NuclearCoffee
Pingback: Tokyo Mirage Sessions Was Originally Going To Be A PokĆ©mon Crossover – India rating
Pingback: Nintendo considerou misturar PokĆ©mon com Fire Emblem – Densetsu!
Pingback: Es posible una uniĆ³n entre Fire Emblem y Pokemon. - nexply Preview
Pingback: Nintendo rozważaÅo crossover pomiÄdzy PokĆ©monami a Fire Emblem | myNintendo.pl
Pingback: Nintendo Thought About Making A PokƩmon and Fire Emblem Crossover | More Pokemon
Pingback: Nintendo Thought About Making A PokĆ©mon and Fire Emblem Crossover – My Nintendo News
Pingback: Hubo planes de fusionar Fire Emblem con PokƩmon
Pingback: Nintendo aveva considerato un crossover tra PokƩmon e Fire Emblem prima di Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE, retroscena sulla nascita del titolo - NintendOn
Pingback: ĀæTokyo Mirage Sessions #FE, crossover de Fire Emblem y PokĆ©mon? - Universo Nintendo
Pingback: Nintendo considered Fire Emblem and Pokemon crossover before moving on to Tokyo Mirage Sessions #FE - Nintendo Everything
FE X Pokemon would’ve been a Nuzloke š
In all seriousness, it’s interesting to know how this game went from one FE X Pokemon crossover to TMS. I’m still busy wondering why it didn’t do so hot in Japan, since that’s where the Idol craze is the biggest.
I’m theorizing that it’s likely due to marketing and the controversy involving the Idol industry. For those who don’t know, Idols have to abide to a bunch of certain rules, one of them being that they ABSOLUTELY CANNOT have a romantic relationship with someone. There was a story about an Ex-AKB48 member that involves one. I believe it was the one who shaved her hair.
Anyways, now that TMS is out in the west, I’m thinking about getting it. I’ve heard the gameplay is top-notch.
Idol life is pretty bad when you look into those downsides, especially things like the AKB48 members and the like.
I haven’t gotten the game myself either, I don’t really have plans to get it either…
My assumption as to why it did not sell well is because Japan has a lot of games like this, so would just be another drop in the bucket compared to the more exotic taste it has for the West. Pair this with the prevalence of handheld systems over home consoles in Japan, and then with the smaller fanbases FE itself may have. The fact it is neither a mainline SMT or FE game may have hurt it among the hardcore fans of both those series who may have been following it since its first announcement, too.
All just guesses of course!